Here was the letter we received from the Scotch Whisky Association. In essence, our letter simply asked them to let this story die, and let everyone go on making wonderful whisky !
Dear Mr Quint
Thank you for your e-mail earlier today regarding ‘Glen Breton’ and for taking the time to set out your views on the matter.
The Association has of course no issue with the production of whisky in countries around the world. However, I am afraid that we will have to agree to disagree on this particular issue. Internationally, many courts have ruled that words commonly associated with Scotland, such as ‘Scot’ and ‘Glen’, should not be used on a whisky not produced in Scotland. We believe that is important so that Scotch Whisky is protected from unfair practices, whether in Canada or elsewhere.
Under the current trademark application, there is no guarantee as to how the trademark ‘Glen Breton’ might be used in the future. While you are aware of its origins, the vast majority of consumers seeing the name, for example, in a price list would be likely to be misled. We sought over a number of years to discuss our concerns with the company in question. Regrettably, they did not respond. The Association was therefore obliged to oppose the trademark.
Whilst I recognise it will disappoint you, I can therefore confirm that the Association intends to appeal the case.
Many thanks again for getting in touch.
Yours sincerely
David Williamson
Public Affairs Manager
Government & Consumer Affairs
Scotch Whisky Association
20 Atholl Crescent, Edinburgh, EH3 8HF, United Kingdom
original post….How Scotch whisky lost battle of the glen
Here is another interesting story on the latest ruling over the name “glen”
A transatlantic battle to stop Canada’s only single malt whisky distiller from using the word glen has been lost after almost 20 years….
….The SWA plans to appeal on the grounds that the principle of barring the use of glen on whisky labels has already been established in the laws of various countries…..
….David Martin, member of the opposition board, said in the ruling: “If the opponent truly believed that the world glen’ merits special protection for producers of Scotch whisky, it should have long ago taken steps to protect that word as a geographical indication of Scottish origin much as it did for the words scotch whisky’…..
the Harold
Popularity: 15% [?]